Feedback on my film magazine cover

Today I got teacher to look and give me feedback on my film cover. She said everything about the film cover was good but she could see no similarities between my film poster and my magazine cover. she personally preferred my film poster as it looked a lot more scary and professional. What I have decided to do is change my picture on my film magazine cover. The picture I am going to use is one I took whilst filming my trailer. It consists of the my actor opening a mirror and the man in the mask is in the reflection of the mirror. The similarities now would be the man in the mask is on both of the posters. I also am going to change the yellow writing to black as I think the yellow writing is to bright and happy for the horror trailer. Black writing will fit in with the genre of horror. Also the I had re-arrange the writing on the left hand side on the magazine so it made more sense and read fluently